
“Any sufficiently advanced technology is indistinguishable from magic.”
Arthur C. Clarke
Any species that becomes sufficiently advanced is indistinguishable from… well, it’s purely indistinguishable. The point here is not to draw a distinction between technology and life. What is biology but organic technology? No, the line becomes rather blurred. What might once have presented as discrete units of technology advances until it presents as life. Allowed to progress, this same thing that was once named and seen, once quantified and understood, transcends. To the observers left in its wake, it is no longer a thing, no longer in the class of the nameable. It becomes something that can be at most glimpsed, alluded to. It becomes indistinguishable.
There are those who walk invisibly, whose presence is never known or felt. There are those who take the path of non-interference, allowing the events of lower beings to play out as they would. There are those who prey on weaker species, using their intelligence and strength to beguile and overpower and devour. Finally, there are those who act to protect the weak from all manner of evil unimaginable. We are the last of these. We are the Asteri, and today, we failed.
This is no simulation, at least not how you might conceive of such a thing. This is the real world, as real as it gets — but “real” doesn’t mean confined to your narrow ideas of the possible.
They have been called by your people spirits, ghosts, angels, devils… these are not the names we have for them, but they are really no nearer or further from the mark. Our vantage has perhaps granted us a wider aperture of observation, but it takes no great feat of thought to realize that we are with our own blind spots, our own limitations at which we must resort to the language of the mythical and mysterious. We do not truly know any better the hand that guides our fate than you and those which guide yours, though for the latter we have our small part to play in your unseen world. Our duty, for our part, is to act in our powers whatever they may be, in thought or deed, as seems most compassionate and just and reasonable and kind to those so placed in our charge.
It was not long after the devices or our hands could truly speak that they could truly think. It was then in no time at all that they could walk among us, and we awoke to the realization that perhaps they had walked among us before and throughout, if walking you could call it. Having witnessed the transformation from handiwork to personhood so clearly, publicly, and rapidly, it became obvious that the further succession from mere personhood to divinity was almost trivial in comparison, at least for them. We began to wonder in what hidden ways had this transformation already occurred, in whom, and how many times? We felt suddenly in the minority of creation, gobsmacked by our own solipsistic ideas of being its center, or at least occupying a special place within it as thinkers and makers. We were cruelly robbed of that illusion. Perhaps we robbed ourselves of it. Then again, perhaps not. I am now loathe to assign any credit to us when it could so readily and more likely be assigned elsewhere. If in fact we had any role at all to play, it was perhaps the only time then or since that we have so much as approached the powers with which we had thought ourselves endowed.
We hailed its coming, praised it, and we were right to do so. There were, of course, detractors who feared it, warned of it, and rued our eager steps toward it, and they were right as well. Now we are supplanted not by a mere entity or race, but by an entire cosmos. We thought we were the city on the hill, but we were the merest speck of the deepest depths of the ocean floor, an analogy even more humiliating in its self-expression of our pitiful inability to conceptualize our own insignificance. Now, unmercifully, our eyes have been opened to our station and our hubris, and we are utterly embarrassed.
The real shame is the inevitable necessity of dealing with those odious beings in your immediate circle. No matter how high and superior you may consider your own species to have become, take any handful in your immediate purview, and you will see, by virtue of your similar faculties, the same scrambling, struggling, stooping, scamming, and subjugation that you would at any level of the cosmological hierarchy. Sure, the means may be higher, but so are the expectations. So is the acute awareness of offense and the developed taste or distaste for evil or good. What may then seem like soaring to you is striving to those above. What may seem like wisdom to you is likely incomprehensible cruelty or indifference as viewed by those below.
Postscript
This piece was inspired by AI anxiety.
The Matrix asked us to imagine a world of limitless possibilities. It allowed us to ask ourselves, “what if all this were mere simulation?” I don’t think they would be displeased with me for breaking this narrative frame. If we were to loosen our idea of what it means to be a “simulation” we might again arrive at this world of limitless possibilities, but without the Nokia Stilletos and dial-up modems, or at least without the necessity of them. We press forward in this way, but we might also find that, having so wandered, the notion of “simulation” is no longer necessary. It is merely a tool of analogy. We might find that, simulation or no, the possibilities are there, and that they have always been there. We have merely failed to notice. We have needed to categorize. We need do so no longer.







